Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Edited: For formatting and from feedback

So if I am getting this right?

  +-------------------------------+--------------+--------+--------+----------+-------+
  |              Lab              |      XL      |   L    |   M+   |    M     | S/XS  |
  +-------------------------------+--------------+--------+--------+----------+-------+
  | Google (Gemini 4 Family #1)   |              | Argon  |        |          |       |
  | Google (Gemini 4 Family #2)   |              | Carbon | Neon   | Hydrogen |       |
  | Anthropic (Claude 5.2 Family) | Fable/Mythos |        |        |          |       |
  | Anthropic (Claude 5.5 Family) |              | Opus   |        | Sonnet   | Haiku |
  | OpenAI (GPT 6.2 Family)       | Astra        | Sol    |        |          |       |
  | OpenAI (GPT 6.1 Family)       |              |        |        | Terra    |       |
  | OpenAI (GPT 6 Family)         |              |        |        |          | Luna  |
  +-------------------------------+--------------+--------+--------+----------+-------+


Notes:

  * Gemini 4 Family
    - Argon   -- ++Train --> Carbon
    - Carbon  -- Distill --> Neon, Hydrogen
  * Gemini 3 Family
    - 3 Pro   -- ++Train --> 3.1 Pro
    - 3 Pro   -- Distill --> 3 Flash
    - 3 Flash -- ++Train --> 3.5 Flash ... -- ++Train --> ... 3.8 Flash
  * "S/XS" classification is due to weirdly low pricing for models by Ant/OAI and not by raw perf
I'm not sure it even makes sense to align models on price given that Neon appears to be considerably better than Sonnet/Terra. Not to mention that there are rumors of a flash-lite type model even faster than Hydrogen.
loading story #50556636
loading story #50556558
loading story #50557692
loading story #50556622
I had a chat with Gemini this morning, Argon seems to be deprecated and replaced by Neon, so neon just occupies argon’s tier now. Argon is no longer selectable on my ultra configured antigravity account.
loading story #50557155
As I understand it, Gemini 4 family should be shifted 1 step to the left. Argon / Carbon are supposed to be XL and in the same class as Fable / Astra.
loading story #50556565
This is illegible on mobile.
loading story #50556307
loading story #50556290
loading story #50556564
loading story #50556995
From looking at the model selection in Gemini Web and Antigravity:

Flash -> Hydrogen (medium level) -> Argon -> Neon Pro -> Carbon

Because Argon and Carbon existed for a while at the same time but treated differently. Pro users get Argon but only Ultra users get Carbon.

I like this. I wish the big sites would categorize like this. For most people XL is not needed. M or M+ is good enough for most. If you really are pushing it then go L.
loading story #50556809
This is a great visualization. Thanks for putting it together. If you'll placate my OCD brain for a second, it does bother me that Google and Anthropic have the oldest models at the top and OpenAI has the oldest model at the bottom.
I have based this on model pricing (which I guess also corresponds to their labs's idea of performance/how they compete) and for google their model cards which specify which model is derived from what
As someone who stayed away from Gemini models as they were apparently unable to reliably use tools for a long time, they could have named the models with UUIDs and would cause less confusion.
loading story #50564101
I don't know how fair this is to openAI. Astra and Sol cost and speed wise could be in two groups, xl+l and l+m respectively.
Whose idiot idea was it to go for a period table naming scheme? Are we supposed to just think that the heavier elements are the smarter models? That doesn't seem to hold up in practice.
Put Astra in L ...
loading story #50557361
The issue is that this assumed the models are not nerfed. But in real life you can find Astra performing worse than Terra or Fable being more or less the same as Sonnet as these companies engage in dirty tricks (selective scamming - some people apparently get full fat models whilst the others don't, so you have people coming and saying works for me you must be dumb and the others say e.g. Opus is crap)
how would you fit in Deepseek
Fable and Astra are not anywhere near the same size. None of the models are priced in a way that is congruent with their size. Honestly wtf is the point in this?