Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> What can you do on a PC that you can't do on your phone?

This is "electricity just comes from the wall" levels of not understanding how things work.

Nothing that runs on a phone is developed or maintained on a phone. Everything that makes the phone work is done on a real computer. It doesn't have to be this way, but Apple and Google and various other parties want it to be this way, so it is. Maybe that will change.

But until it does, the "market share" or "ROI" of a PC is an irrelevant metric. The fact that these metrics fail to capture the value of a PC is an indictment of (your use of) the metrics, not of the PC.

Does the market reward your "value" metric for what a PC is?

If you want to eat and pay your mortgage, are you better off following your metric of "value" in regards to what a PC is?

I dont know, seems pretty relevant to me. I had a dream last night where my mortgage was paid with me tinkering with whimsical products that were grounded in happiness, pluralism, inclusivity and human connection, then I woke up to the good old neoliberal status quo and realized that I have to spend another day at the dream factory capturing peoples attention to pay off my loans and feed myself.

If you want to stick to market dynamics, then focus on that. You asked what can a PC do that a phone can't. The answer, in the context of digital infrastructure, is damn near everything. This is not a metaphysical question, it is an empirical one.

Water is essential for life and yet I can buy hundreds of gallons of it from the local utility for the price of one gallon of gasoline, which I can't even drink. Do not get so hung up on markets as the determiners of all worthiness, they are just allocators of scarce resources.

It's possible the PC will die off (probably through Apple and Microsoft's incompetence), and then the phones will be forced to open up to compensate, but for now I doubt it. They share a common ancestry but they have diverged quite substantially, and this separation has its benefits.

I think the water and gas comparison doesn't make sense here. It's more like the PC is the sparking water with pomegranate flavor and the phone is the normal water. The whole point is that you can do 99% of what you can do with the PC on your phone, if this was not the case the market would be larger
Things a human can do on a PC but not on a phone:

- Software development

- DevOps/system administration

- Industrial automation

- CAD

- (Serious) image/video editing

There are also many "legacy" business processes that are technically doable on a phone but are so cumbersome/limited there that the phone is only really used for things like quick review, small touch-ups, etc. "Microsoft Excel runs the world" is not a trope for nothing.

There are four main reasons for these limitations IMO, in rough order of importance:

1. The phone O/S vendors, who are happy to make most of their platform money through rents on physical-service (often extractive) companies that only pretend to be software companies (like ridesharing and food delivery), gambling, and "free-to-play" video games

2. The software ecosystem, which has largely ignored the use cases I listed above, and so remains fragmented and incomplete (at best) where they are concerned

3. The form factor, which is much more limiting than a monitor+keyboard+mouse/trackpad setup, and can't easily be adapted to compete with the latter except through a dock, but those remain clunky and a bit gimmicky, and no phone even has a Thunderbolt port or other high-bandwidth display-capable connection to properly dock with anyway

4. The hardware, which still shares a lot in common with that of PCs, but has been optimized for things like extremely low power consumption, limited external peripherals, and default-distrust of the end user

And the above is entirely focused on things that make money, this doesn't touch on hobbies, games, and other personal-interest niches.

You can do software development just fine on the phone. Just do "@claude fix my website it's not loading" and everything is solved.

The rest of the listed stuff seems super niche and goes back to the rounding error initial comment.

Like take a step back and think from the average person in the world, not some system administrator, what can the PC do that the phone can't?

Augmented LLMs are potent tools, but they themselves are still made on PCs, and they work best at their tasks when directed by humans on PCs. Such shallow prompts as you gave achieve little more than wasted tokens.

The home-consumer PC market is already contracting and will likely continue to contract. That is not the claim I took issue with. You keep conflating market size with importance. These "rounding errors" run the modern world and will not stop doing so anytime soon.

"work best" is a subjective take, for most people "work good enough" is enough. If the phone works good enough, we don't need PCs.

If it "worked best" and actually mattered, the market would not shrink.

> If the phone works good enough, we don't need PCs.

Sure. It doesn't (yet), so that won't happen (entirely).

However, it does work "good enough" in enough other areas to help explain the contraction. Maybe it will expand into being "good enough" in more areas, and maybe younger people will cause a generational shift that this "unc" can't foresee. But I laid out a bunch of reasons why that's unlikely to happen. I think both PCs and phones are market-saturated, but the replacement treadmill for phones is much faster than for PCs, so the current price shock is hitting PC sales harder.

I think we need an out here to say that PCs will remain for the foreseeable future for businesses and hobbyists, but this won't be enough to sustain the PC market as we know it.

{"deleted":true,"id":50560386,"parent":50555414,"time":1795097668,"type":"comment"}