I think gaming desktops are mainstream but have a longer lifespan now, as AM4 and RTX10xx hardware is perfectly fine for most gamers who play Big Walk or Queen's Domain rather than 8k 240fps Forza. In contrast when I bought a $600 GPU in 2013 (outrageous price back then) it wouldn't be able to handle a medium quality 1080p game in 3 years. So I think both assessments are right: an enthusiast top end rig is more expensive but most gamers simply need less top end rigs every year.
I was using a GTX1060 up until last year, and it still played pretty much everything on decent settings. PC hardware has been long lived for a while, in fact, I think this is one of the factors in the attacks on personal computing.