There are plenty of smart people, but you probably aren't paying them enough to argue and play politics with the imposters that you have also hired. If doing something well also requires convincing a (product) manager that it was their idea, then no one will be doing anything well. The best are going to checkout.
If you get rid of the imposters and lessen the cognitive burden of playing politics to get anything done, it will appear as though all your smart folks started caring.
The thing is that people want a nice life, and most smart people know that martyring themselves will neither save the world nor give them a good life.
The rational thing to do is walk the rim of the proverbial canyon, staying close enough to make good money but far enough away from the Big Questions to never feel like they should become your responsibility to sort out. Because once you agree it should, it’s a self respect hit to walk away without doing something, or do something at personal cost and probably fail to achieve your goal anyway.
Especially since we are not the best people to fix social problems, which very many things are.
no. everyone loses
You can't force people to give a shit, just as you can't impose some arbitrary marker of "smart" or assignment of value that is ultimately some abstraction that is convenient as a heuristic. The assumption that there's some clear and uniform way people would signal that they give a shit is also fundamentally flawed. These are all presumptions built on top of presumptions, heuristics that are cultural-bound and subjective and legible in the high modernist sense, but does that actually serve a meaningful point of reference? The loudest voices in the room only tell you that there's someone who is loud, but whether that is better than someone working their ass off so that the system doesn't get to a point where people feel compelled to be the loudest voice in the room, is open for debate. Hell, why even pretend that these are new problems? There are only so many hours in a day and if nobody gave a shit 5, 7, 10, 15 years ago, at some point one feels like the idiot for giving a shit in the open. Trial lawyers learn real quick that betting on jury verdicts is never a winning move and if even guessing what 12 people would agree on is a fundamentally befuddling experience to people whose job it is to make the point to 12 people in that setting, I think it may be wise to assume that nobody knows ahead of time when or how people would suddenly start to make some showing that is a reliable indicator that they have seen something that crosses some societal red line as well. And really, it just turns a deterministic outcome into a probabilistic one, which sometimes is enough and other times, unbelivably hubristic in hindsight. Three days ago Ofcom in the UK made a recommendation to parliament that is at once wildly outdated and almost certainly already something long attempted in the UK: that CSAM detection should be done via hash-matching. The MD5 hash was first implemented in 1992, and a system as described have in fact been used in practice since before 2010, and by 2012 one can find working demonstrations of hash collisions that made the system effectively useless as implemented. Of course some of us knew before then that the system is unsound, and only a matter of time except explaining why this is vulnerable and unsound was always easier to show than to explain. In 2024 I took a laptop into a suppression hearing and ran some code from the internet that demonstrated that two different files can generate the same MD5 to a judge who, after thinking a few seconds, seemed completely unperturbed and asked what did that have to do with the police database being used to... detect CSAM, which, at the time, was a MD5-metadata based system. People were sent to prison based on this nonsense and if showing the system breaking in real time wasn't sufficient to convince the actual power that determined the admissibility of the broken system as evidence, well, fuck. That was 12 years ago. It now takes less than a second to run much better code that does the same thing. There are hundreds of examples in many languages on Github doing just this. I have no idea what the system currently being used is, but as far as I know, the FBI was still using some similar sort of hash-metadata system that had a degree of metadata detail that is detailed at a level that only those who prosecuted a case involving the production of the material being hashed would have as recently as 2023, according to publicly available filings on PACER in criminal proceedings. Since not even the lawyers involved in defense are privy to even the provenance of the material being hashed, I have no idea if in the interim there was the complete upgrade of the system to a more secure system, but since no significant case requesting convictions made on the flawed data being thrown out had appeared, I'm guessing that the answer is no, because some pseudoscience did finally get recognized as bunk, but certainly after innocent people were executed after being convicted. Orin Kerr, a much better lawyer/tweeter and respected authority oon computer crimes and legal issues, spent two decades of his life advocating for some kind of discernable line when it comes to figuring out a system that is consistent and applicable when it comes to figuring out where the boundaries of permissive access is. This happened in 2020, when the Supreme Court in van Buren v. U.S. adopted a gates-up-gates-down approach that was suggested two decades prior. Before the ruling, there was literally no consistent approach under American law to indicate what counted legally as boundaries in computer access terms. That meant that from the day the world wide web existed until 2020, you can access some publically served document on the clearweb and whether you broke the law was not something you can possibly know. This was why we had a bug bounty system where routinely serious vulnerabilities were discovered but nobody was paid for the discovery. The implicit bargain, which was legally invalid to begin with, was more like a bug-hunter-held-hostge deal: you get the privilege of telling the company of some vulnerability and they promise to not call the FBI anyway, not that the legal system needed that call to prosecute you anyway. The bounty was at most a token gesture that allowed for an NDA to be legally enforceable definitively, since contracts need a bargained-for exchange and consideration in return. You can't use coercion as part of the exchange, unless you are a federal prosecutor, in which case, every case will be an elaborate prisoner's dilemma anyway. The DOJ's conviction rate was only marginally lower than the criminal justice system of China, which is not a real system and widely known to be arbitrary, capricious, and empty. My grandfather, an engineer by trade and a life-long true believer in socialistic ideas, was appointed as a judge on the provincial level in 1979 in China. He asked to be allowed to transfer to a lower post a year later, and ended up in charge of industrial policy and scaling the silk filature system first perfected by JArdine-Matheson in 1865 but transferred to the CCP in 1952 when the company relocated to Hong Kong entirely, and then Bermuda. At the same time, through exercising some of the wide discretionary authority he had, he made arrangements so that his grandchildren, not yet born, would not have to stay in a country where one cannot talk about the manifestly obvious and progress was not made due to merit but luck and happenstance. Unfortunately, even though his grandchildren were in a position to be funneled into the party leadership pipeline in China, the youngest, me, ended up in a system that was, as it turns out, aspirationally more justifiable but in reality, fundamentally still just as unfair as the one he wanted no part in. He passed in 2023 and his state obit did not mention his actual achievements in detail. Even though I have almost no details in my linkedin I routinely get offers to practice law somewhere, and sometimes in fields that I have both experience and knowledge in. But as an ethical matter I have no desire to lend legitimacy where none exist. I have the privilege of not being the clown, and thanks to the choice capitalism afforded me, at least that is an option I can opt into.
To quote the the legendary drag queen Dorian Corey in the 1989 Documentary Paris is Burning, "I used to wanna change the world, now I just want to leave the room with a little dignity left". You may also have heard this in the 2006 film Shortbus. 20 years since, that is, ultimately, still the best most can wish for. Good luck UK, we had tried to put safeguards in place only to see them brute-forced in the most incompetent manner. We forked your repo and even though the codebases are mergeable, we can see the bugs, just as you can see ours. We tried to implement fixes and the patches are still there. Feel free to use the code, it's at least in the public domain, but how you merge that is beyond what we can help you with. The fact is in life as in chess, one may find oneself in a Zugswang. This can be cured, or result in a checkmate, and sometimes happens simply from the first mover advantage. In life sometimes one can see the system being built in a fashion where the outcome is that there is no act that can create a positive outcome, and the stakes are, inevitably, magnitudes greater than a game of chess. I find it curious that many people seem to believe that the counter to this is to rig the system to their advantage in the exact same fashion. I'm not playing that game. I pitched yesterday coach, I'm sitting this out.
Then the name of VC capital, the company started hiring these imposters as leaders.
They are not smart people.
I initially spent some energy on trying to nudge them in the right direction, hoping they were at least somewhat capable.
Then more energy as I reviewed their insane AI slop documents. No substance, and they would not admit they had just generated them via ChatGPT.
Started documenting my answers in writing because they would not actually listen, and instead would just trust their chat bot and preformed opinions over facts. Maybe at least they'd feed my document into it I hoped.
But no, these people are worse than I ever imagined. They think they're smart, but really aren't. They mention AI in every sentence but don't understand it, and actually have the gall to talk over engineers even for technical things, spewing bs with full confidence. Whole rooms rolled their eyes.
I just couldn't believe it. Real scary. And ultimately if it comes down to it they win you lose. The business officially empowers them to "lead", pays them obscene amounts of money and until the company crashes and burns no one will ever listen. And then it's the engineers that get cut.
You're damn right I checked out.
> There are, of course, exceptions (which is why a lot of things are still humming along),
Besides you are taking about smart people who don't give a shit. The main point of TFA is that those don't keep systems alive.
Pretty sure this isn't a pay issue rather than it is a power grab by management and leadership. With AI, they want and can somewhat get the delievered yesterday. No matter what you do to document concerns, they won't care. Have 364 days of production pages, well don't get drunk and miss one on nye.
I lost job 3 times in last 4y because I couldn't deliver.
Piece by piece my desire to fight for good code died.
I'm in charge of couple micro services with high traffic where time is an essence. I understand them but I can't lie myself. This is AI generated slop with my name slapped on it and some day in the future someone will either curse on me or laught from me