Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
What we need is a model that automatically delegates intelligently (via RL and benchmaxxing?) so I can be freed of this burden.
This comment always comes up but isn’t this literally irreducibly complex in the sense of Kolmogorov complexity?

I’m out of my depth here but it does seem prompts have a “smell” to their complexity that means we can use a classifier to mate them to a model with better success than random noise, but still don’t essentially all of the savings associated with systems like this just come because there is some “complexity arbitrage” where there is enough of a token cost differential between models that you always save money by trying the cheap model first and then trying a hard model if it turns out to be hard?

I’m also not an expert but that sounds a lot like the toilet seat problem. Mathematically it’s preferable to just always leave the seat as you used it, instead of using effort to return it to some desired state. This minimises effort in aggregate for all parties. I think it’s possible that routing every request through a simpler model first ends up more expensive in the long run, depending on the cost of that simple model. And if it’s too simple, the routing inefficiencies and mistakes will produce worse results.

I think one of the more difficult problems with this is that the complexity is often unclear at first. It’s not until some thinking and analysis that the complexity emerges. It’s just not possible for a simple model to deduce this, and we don’t want a dumb model investigating a complex issue.

I think in the medium term we end up with large models which are efficient with simple queries. Meaning very few tokens used to answer simple queries, keeping costs low. So one just uses this large model for everything.

Longer term I think LLMs move closer to the structure of the brain, whereby different regions/models have specialised functionality, and they communicate and coordinate depending on the task. For example, telemetry doesn’t need to pass through the prefrontal cortex. It just goes straight to the telemetry model which is super simple and cheap.

loading story #50559908
This is being done at the layer above. "routing" is the term to google.
loading story #50553998
Antigravity has a Orchestrator model that does this.
There's stuff that does this and I've put a substantial amount of time last couple months looking into it, unfortunately you always, always, end up at chicken-and-egg problems.

It's really frustrating to describe. Easiest is you can't score on just the prompt, you need the full context. Ex. "Solve Fermat's last theorem" initial prompt then "continue" followup prompt. Which gets you back in the tarpit of "if I have to pay a model to do an inference run on context, then, the context is cached and I should continue using that model."

The vision of another model thats RL maxx'd on knowing how to delegate has a few problems. One, we can observe externally, it died/didn't work even at OpenAI's scale and willingness to make it work, i.e. the...GPT-5.0? IIRC...router that silently went away. The other, if such a model was built, it'd also be good at regulating it's own thinking enough that it'd naturally use less tokens.

In practice, the frontier hackers have settled on a decision model (i.e. Jev) x calibrating effort level or choosing from a set of models x reasoning effort tuples they specify rules for choosing in their Jev prompt. My guess is this stays stable and the only real choice.

I suspect you are correct but damn if that’s not a deeply unsatisfying conclusion.
Aren't people using jev or similar for decision-making like this?