Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Besides them just being the lapdog of the MPA/RIAA, none of it is great really. In one of the articles MarkMonitor accused RapidShare of being "the leading ‘digital piracy’ site with over 13 billion yearly visitors" while ignoring that the vast majority of those yearly visitors were using the site for legal things and while also ignoring that youtube has far more visitors and to this day is filled with pirated content.

“In an interview with mediapost.com MarkMonitor’s vice president of communications Te Smith said that she did not consider websites like YouTube piracy sites as they ‘have procedures in place where brandowners can take down the material.’ RapidShare offers the exact same take down features to copyright owners as YouTube does. Now, where is the difference?”

Other articles talk about their history of sending unverified and wildly inaccurate DMCA take down notices (for example sending a DMCA notice on behalf of HBO telling Google to remove “infringing” links to what was actually legal content being hosted at HBO.com, and situations where the rights holder didn't authorize them to send notices on their behalf at all), and incidents where MarkMonitor tried to hide evidence from defendants in piracy lawsuits and fought to keep evidence about their operation from the public.