Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
>Which makes your understanding less robust over time as you grow lazy and complacent.

I really wonder about this. Of course it has been bothering me as well. However, when I was young, I have been listening to the same argument wrt/ calculators and the internet vs the good old ways like books and the library. I think this will be the same somehow.

Verification is very easy with AI, I just tell it to bring sources when I feel like it.

Calculators automate a process that can be described by an algorithm and produces deterministic results. LLMs do not produce deterministic results. So they aren't really comparable.

Not using calculators is something you do for learning purposes. Not because you don't trust the calculator's ability to produce correct answers.

This is a technical detail that is orthogonal to my original argument. What do you think about the general idea - that it's about outsourcing thinking, and how good and bad it is, and whether it's just the next step like library->internet search, or something else entirely?
I don't think it is a technical detail. It is the entire point. Calculators perform purely "mechanical work". Answering an arithmetic question isn't thinking it is performing a calculation. Either manually or by using a machine that applies a series of known steps to arrive at a result that is _fully_ specified by mathematics. At no point is there an opportunity to hallucinate a result, for instance.
loading story #50549058