Is the concern that US politicians will compel registrars to take sites down or something?
Not exactly. Politicians write laws, law enforcement hires a prosecutor to enforce the law, prosecutors get a judge to issue a court order, the Company has to comply with the court order or their executives go to jail, the executives are not going to go to jail for you or anyone else. So yes relying on a US company means implicitly that you must follow US law.
But it's worse than that. The CLOUD Act means that even if they use a non-US company, that company can be compelled to release your data to the US, and possibly act on US demands, if the company does business with the US.
Maybe I'm too cynical, I wouldn't expect less from other countries.
If I run a US based company, say a SaaS business, and want to do business in the EU I have to follow their laws with regards to data protections, cookie popups, etc. How is it different for EU companies wishing to do business with US customers being expected to comply with US laws?
loading story #50547878
Yes? They do it quite a lot. They can compel both registrars and registries.