Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
I remember some vsauce (i think) video about how we dont know for sure if speed of light is constant in all directions. As a limitation of measurement we can only measure its speed in a round trip.
It's not really possible to measure the time it takes light to move from point A to B. You can really only measure the time it takes for light to move from point A to B and back.

But you can do measure the difference between light going from point A to point B and light going from point A to point C to point B (and adding point C in the reverse direction as well) and I think you can use that to get reasonable confidence that light has constant speed in a given medium in all directions.

But this is totally relevant for trying to figure out asymmetric delivery delays in packet switched networks... You can't measure the delay directly, and if you use the network to synchronize your clocks, you can't use the clocks to measure the delay either, because most synchronization assumes symmetric delay. You need an externally synchronized clock, like a GPS reference etc.

Let's assume light goes faster in the "north" direction, and slower in the "south" direction.

Wouldn't the north- or south-component of the vectors to C cancel each other the same way they do when going from A–B vs. B–A? If the vector AB is on the north-south axis, and C is somewhere to the east, then the increase in speed from A–C–B would be offset by the decrease on the B–C–A return trip, giving you no information as to what direction is faster.

> It's not really possible to measure the time it takes light to move from point A to B. You can really only measure the time it takes for light to move from point A to B and back.

You absolutely can. Get two synchronized clocks, and start pulsing light at each tick. Then slowly move one clock away and observe how long it takes for the light pulse to arrive.

You don't even need crazy precision for that. A regular atomic clock would do.

Edit: if you didn't get the hint, that's exactly how GPS works.

Usually when people are introduced to the issue of measuring the one-way speed of light, one of the first ideas that comes to mind is exactly what you suggest, and it's a very good first thought, but of course it doesn't work since implicit in your approach is an assumption about what the one-way speed of light already is.

As you "slowly" move the two clocks away from one another, the two clocks will no longer be synchronized due to time dilation, and so you need to account for time dilation, but in order to account for time dilation you need to already know what the one-way speed of light is.

I put "slowly" in quotes because why would it possibly matter whether you move clocks slowly or quickly? It's the principle of the matter that is at issue, not the practicality.

loading story #50538996
When you account for relativity, your idea wouldn't work. You assume that two synchronised clocks would remain synchronised after moving them apart from each other and that's almost certainly not true.

It's an interesting puzzle, but it looks to be impossible to measure the speed of light in one direction due to relativity and time/length dilation effects.

I don't think it's just a limitation of measurement. It's a fundamental limitation of the universe, there's no absolute time so there's no accurate time delta between different frames of reference.

So your time measurement can only be valid for you.

A fun corollary of this sort of relative timing is that a dude casually walking by you when you're sitting still will observe the Andromeda Galaxy with a several day time difference.

> A fun corollary...

I don't think this is quite correct, but I'm not positive myself.

You can't actually make any observations that are several days different from each other, even if you had a miraculous telescope that could see what the little aliens are doing.

You don't actually have any differing observations at all from the person walking next to you (apart from some trivial Doppler effect).

Rather, your frame of reference for what "right now" means in Andromeda differ. And this is not something that ever turns into an observable difference, even if you waited 2.5 million years for the light to get to you to see what the light looked like "right then" in Andromeda, because you'd just be arguing about when that previous "right then" was.

If I remember, Penrose uses this to talk about the nature of time and determinism.

If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me.

> If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me.

You're wrong, GPS needed a relativistic fix for this in software.

> will observe the Andromeda Galaxy with a several day time difference.

If you measure both distance and time, the observations will be near-identical. Likewise, the events observed will be near-identical (perhaps with some miniscule differences in observed event ordering). All that's really different is which parts of the distance are labelled as in space, and which are labelled as in time.

Measurements taken from positions within gravitational fields of the same strength, by observers moving and accelerating in sync (observing no change in distance between them), will be consistent.

I think.

If I walk by you, I observe a change in distance to you
loading story #50559131
While we cannot observe it because we lack an absolute frame of reference, we do know that the speed of light is constant in all directions due to the principle of super-position, provided the medium doesn't change between directions.
Not sure how superposition has any role in this. Sound waves also obey the principle of superposition but sound travels faster downwind than upwind, even though the medium is the same in both directions. So superposition clearly doesn't establish that wave propagation speeds must be identical in all directions.
Sound is a longitudinal wave, the medium velocity is additive to the wave's propagation. Light radiates i.e. it does not require a medium to propagate.
Both longitudinal and transverse waves obey the principle of superposition, yet superposition alone tells us nothing about whether propagation speed is the same in every direction. You're introducing additional properties of electromagnetic waves to justify a conclusion that you originally attributed to superposition.

Superposition has nothing to do with this and does not give any insight into whether the speed of light is the same in all directions.

That's not correct as it is not possible to measure the speed of light in a single direction, but only as a round-trip.

e.g. if light travelled twice as fast to the moon and half the speed from the moon to the earth, there would be no experiment that we could do that would determine that. All clocks and measurements would be the same as if light is constant in both directions.

However, logically we have no reason to think that light does change speed in different directions, so we assume that it's constant.

By the way, what is "the principle of super-position"?

IIRC it was a Veritasium video.

I remember that I thought the hypothesis makes little sense as we define distance as the time light takes to travel. It is the defining constant itself.

That is the current way of defining the meter. It's not the definitive definition of distance.
Not just light, it's impossible to know if the speed of anything is constant in all directions. The so called one-way speed of an object depends on a synchronization convention used for clocks at different locations. Different conventions can produce different one-way speeds while leaving all other observable physical phenomena unchanged.
same argument can be applied to any speed measurement, so it's not actually something profane about light

it's essentially about time zones - you never can be sure that 2 clocks in different locations are in the same time displacement