Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Libraries used to be so amazing to me as a kid, but the quality of books I observe in them now a days seems so much weaker than what I remember from my youth. I'm bit sure if it is because I have gotten older and wiser, or if the material has just dumbed down. I've donated stacks of library quality material but honestly the libraries find it easier to just sell it at their monthly book sale.
Libraries have been gutted to become basically entertainment and a place to use computers for free and watch YouTube. The books are nominally there because it’s a library. Instead the library more and more is becoming a community center, especially as fewer communities have community centers.

The web is part of it, the sense that if I can search google why do I need a book. AI I’m sure just reinforces this. Also though was a trend in making the library more accessible to more people - rather than a place of quiet study, the idea was to make them into a network of community centers with services like training, activities for kids, places for people to meet up, etc; and the books are distributed between branches in a region rather than being shelved in a central library. The books on shelf tend to be the books that are either selected to be picked up by popular demand or to wait for demand at some branch and shipped to the other library. I’ve also found most truly useful books are always checked out with queues very deep. I have a book I’ve been in queue for to borrow for four months. This means the great books of reference or literature don’t show on the shelves because they literally never land on a shelf. They’re constantly in circulation or being held for pickup.

Finally the digital book thing really sucked money out of acquisition of paper books. The licensing for digital books is expensive and they end up with no lasting copies. To make it worse they also have limited licensing per title so you end up queuing again for titles people want to read or are high quality.

Digging under all this though you’ll find the real problem - a million priorities and competing demands, and less funding.

Friendly correction, you mean, "The books are there because it’s a nominally a library."
I've found it useful to immediately flip to the back of nonfiction books to see if they have an index. If a publisher didn't think the book merited a couple hundred bucks to an indexer, it's probably not worth reading at all.
My wife, who is an independent book indexer, thanks you!

It is more like $5-7/page, depending on the topic, depth, etc. She has degrees in Spanish and economics, including a masters, and found a niche doing scholarly books through places like Yale press, on things like Argentinian economics in the 1970s. She should really be charging more, especially since she hasn't upped it in 5 years; some of these books will take several weeks to finish, and she'll make $1.5-2K, but it comes out to like $10-15/hr.

One of my Borland manuals had an index entry of: "Parrots, dead - see dead parrots" (there was no corresponding entry though). I'm wondering, is it common for indexers to have a little fun like that?
I doubt she would get away with that with the types of books she does. She has done books for the National Restaurant Association (NRA, amusingly), which is really the only place she could do it that I can think of. But, most of the time, they will say "We have space for N entries on X pages", and there might be some back and forth on trimming some entries.
My copy of Steele’s Common Lisp used the teenage mutant ninja turtles as an example of something. The index entries for the individual turtles weren’t the page numbers but instead the dates of the respective artists
Could this be a reference to the Monty Python dead parrot sketch?
You can always put in an entry for "recursion" pointing to the "R" page of the index.
I have seen: recursion, see recursion.
The Jargon File's entry on "tail recursion": http://catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/T/tail-recursion.html

Back in the day there was a company called Zenographics that created design, illustration, and presentation software. After the 90s declared winners in that space (Microsoft PowerPoint and Adobe Illustrator), they specialized in printer drivers, and eventually got folded into the chip company Marvell.

The instruction manual for Zenographics Mirage had a glossary, and the last entry was for Zeno, the Greek philosopher who gave the company its name. It included a brief description of who he was and his famous paradox: "Where is an arrow as it flies through the air? At any instant, if it is where it is, then it's not moving, but it can't be where it isn't!"

I never really thought about those sorts of jobs until my cousin ABD'd out of a religious history PhD and got a job as an editor at a state university press. He mostly works with the school of government and edits new legal references and textbooks about that state's government.

Takes a certain academic extremely detail oriented mindset, but works out as a much more normal 9-5 career than other options you'd think of in the humanities.

Thank you for correcting my mistake, I hadn't thought about how long ago I heard that stat.
Some modern books also performatively contain an index but the index is too short and does not have many common phrases. It seems like having an index is a checklist item, without paying attention to the quality of the index.
surely people too cheap to hire an indexer would just use some computer program to do it (?)
Finally a use case for LLMs. So what if the page numbers are wrong or the word is not actually present on the page. Or in the book. There is a index and that is what people asked for.
From what I heard libraries rarely accept personal donations and they usually sell them. I think books are less amazing nowadays, just because there are so many of them, so the average quality is...not amazing.
Back in the 90's I would go to library book sales. I was actually shocked that libraries got rid of books but I remember buying 20 books for about $30. It was amazing and I still have them.

A few years ago I bought a 3 volume set about the space shuttle from someone on ebay. I was surprised to find that they were former library books. It looks like no one ever borrowed them and they were in great shape.

I've also noticed that at 2 of the used book stores in my city they have signs that say "No former library books."

Kind of sad but I guess the library and the book store knows what people want more than I do.

I have been to exactly one book sell and decided to never go again. None of the books on sale interested me, and I realized that, if I want to read a book, chances are that I can find them in my local library or via interlibrary loan. If a book doesn't exist in the catalog, I probably don't want to read it in the first place. (This has held true for me over the past decade.)

As someone who is VERY heavy in ebooks, borrows many books on Libby and avoids personally owning physical books, this feels a natural choice for me.

I often find that my county doesn't have it, but they can get it via inter library loan. I rarely go to my library any more except to pick up books from elsewhere.
Our library has renowned book sales. Their ephemera and sheet music section is quite good
i bought TONS of books as a teenager from a Cleveland suburb branch funded by Carnegie. it was Christmas in the summer for a nerdlinger between xc workouts solder-hacking his PS1. before that so many Choose Your Own Adventure books then Bill James

i don't know the specifics, but Denver (also heavily supported by Carnegie) has large book stuff every week and a dedicated little wing. in this age i am very pro-library. i accidentally stumbled up the Blair-Caldwell African American Research Library yesterday. (edit: i forgot i had a postgrad fellowship at a major uni library such is life). on a related note, bookstore drama is peak Denver performance art right now

to keep today on topic who among the AI Cylon Final Five overlords think they are the Carnegie of tomorrow's libraries

>"No former library books.

"No books that some other book professional deemed not worth it, we only want the stuff from people who don't know what they got"

Probably more that they don't want to encourage people stealing library books to make a few dollars selling them. It's probably an enormous hassle for the bookstore and the library both
Here I think library books would have lower value compared to their unmolested counterparts. And I mean stuff like possibly wrapping it in plastic, cutting the dust jacket, labels on spine, stickers for bar code and inside to hold the card they used decades ago. Oh and a few stamps for being sold...
Next time somebody recycles the meme about "the reader doesnt steal, the thief doesnt read" proverb from alleged modern day Irani booksellers who dont lock their wares, I got the perfect reply.
Well, I don't know anything about that expression but, in this case, the thief (that steals from the library to sell to the bookstore) doesn't read, and the reader who buys them used didn't steal anything.
Do you have kids/regularly go to the library?

I rediscovered the library when I had kids and they aged up to reading ages. Libraries are still great. An absolutely wonderful asset to get kids reading without using screens, which is absolutely important.

The only difference is libraries do host a lot of content, so you should do some exploration of what types of books you're looking for ahead of going to the library. Or, better yet, use your local library app to browser their index at your leisure.

For young children's books, just grab stuff off the shelf that is engaging and aligns with your parenting approaches. For young kids, you're just trying to make the experience fun - including going to the library. Most libraries also should be doing activities too, which is also engaging for young kids.

Yeah we go there frequently. They also sell books very cheaply, like one buck for a book, 75 cents for a children’s.
I don't think very many libraries loan out donated books. It's cheaper for them to buy the book from a vendor who prepares it for their system than to pay staff to do the same with a donated book (Ingram is one of these companies, I'm sure there are others).
Libraries have limited space for books. They need to choose the best, donated books might or might not be the best for the people there.
The price of a shelf-ready book from Ingram is probably less than the cost for the library to prepare the exact same donated book for the shelf.
Re: quality drop, it's the same in actual bookstores. I am stunned by how much of the non-fiction section consists of books quickly knocked out by, basically, internet content writers, helped or already outright replaced by AI. The quality of the visual presentation (elaborate binding, color scheme) seems to have gone up, because apparently many customers now want a book mostly for decor, but the actual contents are dreck.
I worked in the campus main library, while I was studying to get my BS-CS degree. I worked there for almost five years. It was amazing. And I knew both the Dewey Decimal system, as well as the Library of Congress system. And both made sense to me.

The way bookstores do it is okay, bust doesn’t make nearly as much sense to me. But then many bookstores have closed, for various reasons.

So, maybe bookstores aren’t the right model for how a library should be organized?

Arguably libraries are, well, dense libraries of data. Problem is you need to know what you are looking for to find your data.

Bookstores, IMO, are more stochastic/discovery-based. I’ve walked into a good number of bookstores without a target in mind, and still walked out with a book or two.

Recently, I went to our local library and tried to do the same - went in with a general idea of what I was interested in reading. Walked out empty-handed.

From my experience, I’d say there definitely seems to be some positive benefits to transitioning away from a strict numbering system and more to something “organic” (for a lack of a better term).

If you know the Dewey numbers of your interests, related stuff you might like is to the left and right of that point so it's not too bad to find related topics.

What really bugs me about libraries is fiction, knowing what you want, say Asimov. They might have it under Sci-fi, YA, mystery, or any one of a dozen special interest shelves like Robots or Future or whatever.

loading story #50560275
Both systems are good for browsing a genre. In curation, one needs to do a higher dimensional join. Say for the history of America you might have a recipe book next to Japanese Internment.
loading story #50570324
Ours outright refuses to accept any book more than 4 years old.
I know this seems strange, but it usually has to do with the scarcity of hands and relative abundance of books, and their life cycles in a library.

Hardback books can be lent out approximately 25 times before breaking and paperbacks much less - 5-8 times is normal. Libraries often try to protect the books by strengthening the spines and applying an extra layer on the cover and such, but this is more trouble to do and less worthwhile if the book is already used and has had a couple of lending cycles shaved off its lifetime. In most cases it will therefore be a better investment to sell a donation and buy new books of known quality and invest your limited man-hours in those.

There is also such a thing as a library binding, which is much more rugged than the books you buy at a bookstore.
It is not cheap but the books basically last forever. My fav books i cover with tape.
It sits between hardcover and paperback in price. I have a fair amount of library bound books in my personal collection - if I'm going to keep it on my shelf that implies I want to read it more than once and in turn quality is worth paying for. (though more than once I've found my collection re-arranged by size/color or something else that looks good and makes finding the related books impossible, so there is apparently a large group who thinks of book collections as only decoration)
It’s not that it’s strange, is that the result is that many libraries today are filled almost exclusively with slop and are deaccessioning anything old. Many of them are just entertainment centers.
5-8 times? There were YA paperbacks at my childhood library that I personally borrowed more times than that, and they weren’t new when I got there.
This is from memory based on what I was told working at a library so I might be wrong and 5-8 is when you needed to bring them in for repairs.

Either way it swings wildly depending on quality and tecnical aspects of the binding and paper, and the specific trajectory of each book. You'd be surprised how rough some people treat library books.

Many libraries aren't libraries anymore, probably because of the closure of so many other buildings.

Here's what my 'library' does:

- Refugee welcome sessions

- Computer assistance

- Maker space

- Kids classroom / events space

- Local government (council) signposting

- Hosting of cultural events

- General hangout areas, you're free to bring snacks and meals etc

- Public toilets

- Dedicated warm/cool space for when it's hot/cold

Unsurprisingly the quality of the books has nosedived as the focus has shifted to a general third space of last resort. Frankly as an older local interested in learning, it's quite alien.

IMO this mixture of trying to be everything to everyone isn't great: it's too noisy, people make a mess, the homeless hangout all day, staff are stressed from doing 6 different jobs

The philosophy collection isn't even a whole small shelf. Barely any classic English literature

Many libraries are also the true last standing Blockbuster for things like video rentals, sometimes videogame rentals, and sometimes music rentals. I've even seen board game rentals at one local library especially dedicated to teenagers.

Commercial interests got bored of these spaces outside of subscription services and subscription services add up in costs to many underserved audiences, so libraries fill the gap. Sometimes an important gap, especially as Syndication has also sort of "died" and a lot of culturally "important movies" and shows no longer show up on broadcast TV because they are "streaming exclusive" but still for collectors are producing physical media, for the moment. (That is shifting, too, with some of the streaming services producing less and less physical media as well, and major stores like Target and Best Buy leaving physical media of movies and TV almost entirely.)

Ironically, the library from the featured article is actually in the same town as the last remaining Blockbuster video
The central public library in the city I used to live in was renovated to one of these general third places, and it does have the drawbacks you mention* and few actual books. But people who wanted to read serious books and in silence could still visit any of the academic libraries in the city, or the country's national library.

* (But also advantages. Young people seem to happy to have got a place to hang out in cold months without having to spend money; the only alternative had been expensive eateries and malls.)

I remember the academic library at my college was stuffed with an amazing variety of academic books and had strong inter-library loans and login access to research databases, but the physical space itself functioned primarily as a workspace with varying noise levels. (the floor you walked in on allowed normal talking and as you went up or down a level from there it got quieter until the silent floors). We pretty rarely checked out books other than the sets they maintained of 2-3 copies of every assigned course reading.
I don't disagree, as I do see some of these "features" in Bay area libraries (Northern California, USA). And even see some other "features" that are very questionable for a library like indoor, 2-story children's playgrounds (yes, really). But I still thought the books availability and access to e-literature are still great.

Out of curiosity, where are you observing this?

I think imagining libraries as being "learning spaces" make sense. Having a book on how to make stuff, and a maker space where you can borrow equipment to make the stuff seems very complementary.

I agree generally on being a shelter - You cant do both and do a good job at doing both.