Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Yeah I had the same impression. There was plenty of data presented and code was dumped and reversed…but was the actual issue solved? What even was causing the issue? Presumably it passed smog sometime in the past couple years so what degraded? It was lean and there was some kind of issue with pressure. I can’t imagine a reflash or whatever is the fix.

It definitely feels like a classic case of the operator reinforcing Claude to keep pursuing a goal that’s counterproductive to a robust solution. Claude complied and they went hard on it but I can’t imagine the driver is any better off and more likely in a worse spot as the underlying issue wasn’t solved.

”You attach an assumption to a piece of evidence, you start to bend the narrative to support it. Prejudice yourself.”. I find by default while claude is great at analyzing logs and diagnostics from a variety of places it is really prone to this bad detective pattern of choosing an explanation and sticking with it even when evidence starts to bend away from it. you really have to play the role of the skeptic to do do good root cause analysis. Which is very hard to do in unfamiliar domains.
It's probably a bad MAF sensor but this guy thinks he knows more than he does and uses the king of incorrect confidence to try to diagnose the issue.