Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> This is a very clear agpl violation

clear in what way?

As clear as "can I take a copyrighted photo, use a photoshop filter on it, and then it's not copyrighted anymore?" is pretty clearly a solved question in any copyright system.
I think that this is actually a complex topic in copyright law that requires case by case analysis. It clearly is possible to cut out things from magazines, glue them together to form a collage and create a copyrighted work of art. In my naive opinion sufficient photoshop filtering can thus create a new copyrighted work.
AGPL states that anything in-memory with AGPL code on a server is now subject to AGPL. Fairly clear to me. https://spdx.org/licenses/AGPL-3.0-or-later.html
It doesn't say that. Your thinking of dynamically linked code. In-memory makes it sound like two programs loaded into the same stick of RAM.
What's more dynamically linked than something unexpected the user requested, but it was brought forth upon demand?
It means a dependency for the program not data for the user. Uploading a GPL file to Dropbox doesn't make everything on their server GPL that would be crazy.