Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Whether if using ML models as a form of IP laundering, is legal or not, still seems to be an open question. It's not ridiculous at all. If I lossy-compress Harry Potter, then unzip it in a way that mixes some words, is that fair use? Should I be financially rewarded for my "work"? Is this work now mine? If it is legal, why not just go through every book in this kind of automated fashion and start selling them as my own?
My question is still the same. Human devs have learned from open-source projects, books and code on the internet then used opensource frameworks to create proprietary software logic.

Now just because same devs use AI to create code doesn't mean they should be banned from creating or owning a proprietary software.

The difference is the scale. Yeah, some mice and small birds are eaten by bigger predators. Doesn't mean that introducing cats to that ecosystem won't be disastrous.

Same with the ecosystem of creative work. Will some humans be inspired by my code or other artifacts? Sure. Does it mean it's fine to introduce an automated 1000 times more effective plagiarism machine to that ecosystem? Probably not. Certainly not if avoiding destroying the ecosystem is your consideration.

This needs to be addressed as separate issues.

Open source code: reproducing and publishing the code without following the license is a copyright violation. Instruction a computer programme to do the same thing should still be a copyright violation. Since this is the internet, I need to state the obvious: trivial code (defined on a case-by-case basis) is not copyrighted.

Books: the author expects you to reproduce their work, as long as it’s not another book. You wouldn’t get many sales if you sued someone for using the things you taught them.

The internet: actually the same as open source code. StackOverflow enforces a specific licensing clause to allow people to use code you provide. People who write posts that say “use this code to fix this problem,” are implicitly providing a license, too.

I don’t think using an LLM to generate code should remove its copyright but it also doesn’t remove the responsibility to not violate copyright.

Given how agents are already able to easily decompile software, this could be an entirely moot point.
I haven't heard of this. When did this happen?
loading story #50510301
I don’t see why a person who did not use their own creativity to produce code should be given copyright for it.

In fact, current US law says AI output cannot be copyrighted.

What is transformative enough to be legal is fuzzy. At the end of the day, it only matters how the courts rule. I do know that the amount of actual mechanical change has less bearing on determining if the work was transformative. There are cases where you can copy 90% of a code base verbatim legally, and there are cases where no code is copied verbatim and it is a copyright violation. What you are describing most likely would not fly in court.
>If I lossy-compress Harry Potter, then unzip it in a way that mixes some words, is that fair use?

I mean, you don't even need such a contrived example to make this point. What if I just took Harry Potter and replaced the names of all characters and unique items, locations, and concepts with different names? Is that fair use?

Of course it isn't. How would that be determined? A court would have to decide, but it would be a straightforward case against me.

But what if I created a new novel that effectively has the same plot points as Harry Potter but is truly written independently? Anybody could see I was "inspired" by Harry Potter, but it's not like JK Rowling owns the concept of a wizard or a coming of age story. They could try to sue, but odds are, in that case, the court would easily rule in my favor.

All of this is to say that IP laws are based on human judgement. Without human judgement, IP laws don't really work. The line is drawn based on how humans perceive two pieces of work. If humans perceive them as being "too" similar, then it's a problem. Otherwise, it's just the nature of information diffusion across society.

Note that none of this depends on how that work is created. That doesn't matter. If you wrote a word-for-word replica of Harry Potter despite genuinely never hearing about it once in your life, then you still aren't allowed to sell it as your own.

>Should I be financially rewarded for my "work"?

This depends entirely on the market, not on any moral or ethical notion of what you might "deserve." If you've obeyed IP laws, then whether or not you should be financially rewarded is based simply on whether or not people are willing to pay you for your work. Is it cheap slop that anybody could generate themselves with free AI? Then don't expect many people to pay you. Is it a clever idea that nobody would have thought of that requires some ingenuity or set up that most people can't be bothered with? Then maybe people will be willing to pay you. Again, it doesn't really matter where it came from. If you're following the law and people are willing to pay you, then you're good to go.

>Is this work now mine?

Sure, specifically because you were the one to put in the effort to own it. That's basically all there is to it.

>If it is legal, why not just go through every book in this kind of automated fashion and start selling them as my own?

Please, do so. But note that (a) this is already happening on a massive scale and (b) that market is so saturated that nobody doing this is making any money. The laws of economics still apply even if some people take moral issue with AI while others couldn't care less. If something takes you basically 0 effort or cost to produce, then why would others want to pay you for it?

I think an important aspect of all of this is to recognize that IP laws aren't very "logical" in the sense that protecting IP comes more from human "inefficiencies" than it does economic ideals. IP laws are in-place to encourage people to produce valuable IP in that they can have some assurance that the invested time, energy, and money into some IP won't be wasted because someone else just takes what you produce. It's important for our society, but it's not some inherit, fundamental aspect of morality. If AI makes it so that such an investment of time, energy, and money is simply a waste, we shouldn't support that waste for the sake of upholding IP laws. That's backwards. It's the same kind of issue you see with patent squatting, but now this is occurring at such a scale that it's starting to really highlight the issues with IP laws when they don't actually support society prosperity.