Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Is it unenforceable to check that a company openly all in on AI is releasing all the source code of their products?
They don't have to release anything and most of these companies don't care about openly violating the license terms even if they are caught.

Unless the license holder has a lot of money for litigation, it is unenforceable.

They don't "have" because they have more money?

You're free to take that bet, we'll see.

> They don't "have" because they have more money?

My point is, if you don't have a lot of money to start litigating against the violations, the opportunists don't care and will continue to trample all over your "free and open source" software.

It not enforceable without a lot of money and the opportunists know that.

> You're free to take that bet, we'll see.

There is nothing to bet here. Truth Social is a clone of Mastodon (AGPLv3) and all they did was disclose the vanilla source code and not the modifications which that is required by the license. [0]

The same happened with Revolt (AGPLv3) and Andrew Tate's platform [1] and they never released any of the source code at all, nor could the developer enforce anything. [1]

[0] https://help.truthsocial.com/legal/open-source/

[1] https://insrt.uk/post/andrew-tate-stealing-software-revolt/

Those cases are about going against the president, who has even the majority of the supreme court standing by him, and about a young guy against a company reportedly behind shell trusts, owned by someone with no concern for the law and important political ties.

I don't know if lawsuits were even attempted, but I wouldn't infer that open source licenses are unenforceable from those cases.

Anyhow, what do you mean that Truth didn't disclose the modifications? I saw that they didn't initially, than they complied with a request in 2024; but, yes, I see that it hasn't been updated since. Has someone tried to request the current source code?