Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

FM-1 Workbench

https://open.m-vave.com/fm1-workbench
Our algorithms must all be feeding us the same things, I was about to buy one of these yesterday. I've been excited by the various Groovebox firmwares in particular.

I play music by sight (poorly) and can improvise a little bit on guitar, and would love to understand music theory better but so far do not.

Is this a useful device to get a feel for creating music, or is it only really useful if you already understand music theory or improvisation?

loading story #50488977
loading story #50489132
loading story #50491058
loading story #50489167
loading story #50491474
loading story #50488953
loading story #50489368
loading story #50489259
It's been a great little toy, I install a new firmware every couple of days. I especially enjoy the various generative firmwares.

Many of them work in browser too, which is essential for choosing what to try next!

Some faves:

NACHTFART: https://fartypants.github.io/fm1-nachtfahrt/emu/

DUB-1: https://sbegueria.github.io/fm1-dub/emu/

The explosion of firmwares for this device, and the manufacturers embrace thereof, is a rare bright spot in post-LLM music tech
loading story #50489387
My first FM-1 is out for delivery. I once assisted in a 2" tape studio, I have played with many synths, and yet I am so excited for this little thing.

This is such a cool hardware meme/software/ai dev thing that makes me very happy for the world.

I am just about to start learning. If anyone could drop firmware knowledge aside from Baud Girl (cool af) ... I would appreciate it. I am mostly excited about Obervave, but I will have two FM-1's shortly... what is the best step sequencer firmware at the moment?

loading story #50488727
loading story #50488676
loading story #50488683
Downsides immediately jump out at me, it lacks real DIN MIDI ports, having those irritating 1/8" jacks instead which require an adapter. Built in battery, hopefully not too difficult to replace. I vastly prefer AAs for this use case like the Volcas use. It has a fan, that's not good at all. It looks cheap (look at the bottom photo here https://www.m-vave.com/product?id=fm-1) and not sturdy. Similar to my Elektron Moden Cycles and my Polyend Tracker, a bit flimsy and cheap.

I feel like the Chinese have made and sold enough music gear on behalf of other manufacturers over time that they can technically make the products, but I don't think they understand the market so they will be flawed and toy-grade for a while until they hire some consultants and carefully study the various portable MIDI gear that has succeeded over time. I'm not sure what the electronic music scene looks like in China but I would suspect most of the people involved still use non-Chinese gear and software.

loading story #50489563
loading story #50489791
loading story #50489112
loading story #50489121
I got one for my kid's obsessed with music composition. What would you use this with so they can compose multitrack tunes, something like Chrome Music Lab or Beepbox? Anything in Android so they can compose on the go, such on an aeroplane?
loading story #50488811
loading story #50488793
loading story #50488761
loading story #50488861
Was just looking at this teardown https://www.reddit.com/r/synth/comments/1vgotkd/mvave_fm1_te...

I don't know anything about synthesisers, but would I be right in thinking the FM modulation would be done via software on the MCU?

loading story #50490037
loading story #50489467
loading story #50490192
It seems they also have the SMK-37, which is not that much more expensive, but has actual keys so probably more useful for actually playing music, and apparently most alternative firmware support it too.
loading story #50489713
They will also be releasing a FM-2 (a slightly larger version but details are slim) later this year. No details on pricing either but assume it will be priced in similar respects to the FM-1 (little bit more for a little bit extra stuff)
loading story #50491047
Wouldn’t it be wonderful if when you clicked “about” on a website, it would tell you about the website .
FM-1 is really nice because it's basically a platform with Bluetooth, WiFi, screen, speaker, audio out, usb, rechargeable battery, knobs and buttons in ready to use package. You can build anything with it (considering small CPU and ram).
loading story #50489546
What API does this use that isn't available in Firefox?
loading story #50489465
What is the right way of thinking about frequency modulation for musicians? I know some of the maths but I can't operate the bitwig FM-4 synth. Do you just screw around with the thing until you can operate it?
loading story #50489163
loading story #50488903
loading story #50488864
loading story #50490948
loading story #50490522
This device is really cool. Started to get into music production with a dawless setup and with an FM-1 you can use DX7 patches and with some firmware choices you can turn a $50 machine into a groove box.

Think this bodes well for the future of Chinese consumer electronics. They have really been punching above their weight. Even the "cheap" guitar pedals are better than what you'd find with American/EU equivalent companies while being 60-80% cheaper.

Just a shame that Chinese workers are too often exploited.

loading story #50489139
Completely off topic, but if you are a boomer with an iOS device, there are PLENTY of electronic music apps [and emulators] on that platform too.

PS: and I mean PLENTY !

I find it fascinating. Basically people get ability to run AI made crap vst plugins in a calculator sized box and yet they go crazy about it.

I wonder how long this will last.

This also got companies like Behringer an idea that they can just release the hardware and people will create firmware for free. Genius.

edit: that reminds me I actually bought one too, but forgot about it. Still unopened.

loading story #50489229