Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
This is just the AI grift and uneducated hypebros. There is zero reason to use an LLM as a classifier. But AIbros with zero technical knowledge will push for it anyways even if it is 1000x slower and 1000x more expensive to run.
You can can't build an SVM-classifier for a ticketing system without domain data. You can ask an LLM to do it, and it will do it very well.

With the LLM you don't even need a data scientist to train the model, you just need someone who can connect to APIs. And the LLM is fine with adding and removing categories. No retraining.

It makes the initial faces incredibly fast. Then it is slow and expensive to run, so once the system settles, it becomes the target for model optimization, e.g, a dedicated, or semi-dedicated model.

loading story #50437687
I can spin up a classification solution with an LLM in ca. 5 minutes that is likely to do an okay job. To build a custom classifier, I need lots of training data first.

That is the reason.

Once you then have a system that is used enough, it starts making sense to look to replace that with a leaner classifier, but LLMs have a place in vast number of places where we'd previously never use a classifier because it was too much effort.

loading story #50437555
There are absolutely good reasons to use smarter things for classification. Svm with tdf idf for example is super fast but will make very bad classifications at times in ways entirely unfixable with that system (thinking back to bats being an acronym for a theology degree classification or similar)
This is a bit too radical and misses some nuance. In order to start building classifiers you at least need some ML domain knowledge, like what to google at least. Meanwhile, point anyone at the jev/open-jev-clones API and have them start classifying in <10 minutes. There's some value there. (same used to be valid for LLMs before jev became a thing. You can use llms as zero-shot classifiers with the right API wrapper, w/ no domain data).
loading story #50439291
1000x more expensive run can be overall cheaper. You avoid upfront training/tuning cost. It all depends on your scale.