Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
AnthonyMouse | on: Breaking the open web won't stop the bad bots
> A web browser isn't a bot as long as it's controlled by a human but it becomes one once it's automated.

That doesn't mean anything. All of the code in a browser is "automation" -- normal users aren't hand-crafting the hundreds of HTTP requests the browser makes to render a single web page. Meanwhile there is a human somewhere telling the scrapers what to scrape.

> You are entitled to your own emails, posts, etc

Is that somewhere in the proposed text?

> but you are not entitled to crawl the internet for your own purposes without stating what they are and allowing websites an opt out.

"Stating what they are" buys you nothing when you have no way of verifying it, and you're still not providing any way to distinguish this from investigative journalism or e.g. a new competing search engine.

card_zero | parent | next
Using a computer to do "by hand" is a vague concept, yes, but laws routinely embrace vague concepts. You used it yourself! "Hand-crafting", you said. It could be pinned down more closely to something like a single action that happens quite soon after you press a button or ... and further wrangling could ensue because it's never going to have all the vagueness removed. It's probably relative to current norms of computer use and what we do or don't automate casually (and thus describe as "by hand").
loading story #50310061
za_creature | parent
> All of the code in a browser is "automation"

I don't think you are interpreting what I said in good faith, but here goes:

If you use an API to control a browser into navigating to a certain webpage, as opposed to using human interface devices to assert said control.

And no, AI is not a human interface device.

loading story #50311407