Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
How is this any different than terra, sol etc or leopard, yosemite etc, or model x, y, 3, s ..
Don't know about the leopard and model x, but at least in the case of OpenAI luna > Terra > Sol > Astra is a pretty obvious size progression.

But I come from a latin language background, so maybe I'm a bit biased there.

loading story #50278244
loading story #50278849
loading story #50278203
loading story #50278743
Astra > Sol > Terra > Luna seems clear enough to me

Leopard (10.5) and Yosemite (10.10) both came with clear version numbers

Model X and Model Y are siblings which do not have a clear hierarchical relationship

Gemini 4 Carbon and Gemini 4 Argon are rather difficult for me to tell at a glance

loading story #50280108
loading story #50283072
Luna/Terra/Sol/Astra make perfect sense, it indicates model tier/size with larger celestial body representing larger model.

Same for Anthropic, consistent model tier naming reused across model generations.

Those are just like i3/i5/i7 or M-series Pro/Max/Ultra.

But Carbon seems to be full replacement of Argon announced two weeks ago, they're same price. So Argon doesn't mean anything, they just picked random element.

loading story #50280927
loading story #50280496
FYI, Model S, 3, X, Y is an acronym for S E X Y.
loading story #50278860
loading story #50281216
loading story #50280006
Would it have been so hard to call it Gemini 4.1 or 4.5?
loading story #50278041
terra/sol or opus/haiku give an indication of size (the sun is bigger than the earth, opus is larger than a haiku). Carbon is smaller than argon (periodic table speaking), so that's no longer a helpful way of thinking about the model sizes...
{"deleted":true,"id":50278398,"parent":50277942,"time":1793211348,"type":"comment"}