Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Tell HN: I unknowingly broke the PHP RCE embargo. I am sorry

loading story #50202361
loading story #50200322
loading story #50195162
loading story #50193835
loading story #50203948
loading story #50199396
loading story #50202961
loading story #50196080
loading story #50202884
loading story #50202183
loading story #50213382
loading story #50204952
loading story #50201448
loading story #50214819
loading story #50209471
loading story #50206471
loading story #50206428
loading story #50201846
loading story #50216964
loading story #50205771
loading story #50200685
loading story #50202837
loading story #50206031
loading story #50201608
loading story #50206402
loading story #50209286
loading story #50204444
loading story #50204892
> I have learned my lesson.

It is not your lesson to learn. You tried to be helpful, in a way that you had no idea was verboten. Unlearning being helpful is not a good outcome of this.

It being a potentially massive security issue, taking care to make sure it is safe to release the information is definitely something that should happen, but it appears that you did this:

> My contact had told me there was no embargo, and her contact had told her the same thing.

I'm pretty sure I'd have been more cautious given that the CVE details were not minimal, as this usually implies that releasing the details is expected to cause early exploitation¹, and wouldn't have discussed it as publicly as on HN, but don't kick yourself too much for having done so. You did not break the chain, someone before you, maybe several links before you, did by telling others without giving them information about the need for an embargo.

--------

[1] Perhaps that is a lesson to learn, rather than the not being helpful one? Even then that is a small correction to your level of caution, the big lesson (“FFS be careful, things are embargoed for a reason”) is still for those before you in the chain.

loading story #50205237
loading story #50202730
loading story #50206609
loading story #50204112
loading story #50200853
loading story #50195688
loading story #50204036
loading story #50207147
loading story #50203115
loading story #50207972
loading story #50203157
loading story #50201628
loading story #50204158
loading story #50201571
loading story #50204222
loading story #50203876
loading story #50200190
loading story #50207108
loading story #50203766
loading story #50203694
loading story #50205117
loading story #50202009
loading story #50204569
loading story #50201616
loading story #50202093
loading story #50204143
loading story #50200832
loading story #50200538
loading story #50193889
loading story #50201304
loading story #50208513
loading story #50204711
loading story #50205238
loading story #50203511
loading story #50203042
loading story #50200525
loading story #50208134
loading story #50194880
loading story #50201633
loading story #50202032
loading story #50198993
loading story #50200311
loading story #50195988
loading story #50200583
loading story #50201180
loading story #50204049