Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
You lost me when you said trains and cars shouldn’t go over 30mph. Lol, this sounds like Amish propaganda. Go buy your horse and buggy
Another dry sarcasm victim. If you check the link, it’s clear they were talking about a supposed contemporary concern about health effects from trains, the implication being that today people are also irrationally afraid of tech.

Problem is I’m fairly sure the link is wildly overstating its case, and looks like a content farm. Might even be, ironically, AI slop itself! For example, it talks about “railway spine”: “Physicians of the time believed that the jarring motion and vibrations of train travel could shatter the nervous system, causing lasting mental and emotional distress.”

This is bullshit. As just one example of the low trustworthiness of the “article”, railway spine was the result of a train crash, a notably traumatic event, and the symptoms described are in part just PTSD, a real condition and a real concern (not normal rail travel). For that matter railway travel in those days was genuinely unpleasant (lots of vibrations and jarring movement, poorly ventilated cars, and so on) which ironically modern science would probably validate as being some kind of health risk.

I’d actually view the listed example of train paranoia a great example of historical ignorance. People of the past were not stupid, contrary to popular belief. History has some genuine examples of silly hysteria, but these are usually the exception not the rule.

> fairly sure the link is wildly overstating its case

Sorry for the particular link, I'd grabbed whatever.

If one takes a minute, one can find contemporary newspaper articles. IIRC, many were about how people could suffocate.

https://books.google.com/books?id=Lm03AQAAMAAJ&pg=PA337&dq=t...

Contemporary women's health:

https://books.google.com/books?id=9-FXAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA71&dq=ho...

And contemporary survey of fears:

https://books.google.com/books?id=-RdAAAAAcAAJ&pg=PA107&dq=%...

Aaand, a 2023 takedown of claiming claims about historical tech hysteria:

https://www.wired.com/story/technology-predictions-history/

A common belief right now in the US military is that even the blast of a high caliber ammunition round may scramble your brain and give you "PTSD".

It does line up with "PTSD" only becoming a thing after WWI.