Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

European sunscreens are safer than American (2024)

https://www.ms.now/opinion/msnbc-opinion/sunscreen-united-states-fda-ingredients-rcna153526
> Not at all. In fact, American sunscreens may be less safe.

Are they less safe, or _may_ they be less safe? The distinction is important, and I'm wary of overexcited editors "upgrading" titles for clicks.

(This is a comment on the veracity of the title claim only - I'm British, I have no skin in this game)

loading story #48505766
loading story #48505818
loading story #48506321
Didn't the FDA clear new ingredients this week? https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/09/well/fda-sunscreen-bemotr...
loading story #48505166
loading story #48505457
loading story #48505363
loading story #48505157
loading story #48506088
The FDA did (3 days ago!) finally approve a new ingredient: https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-expa...

My personal hot take is that we should all be using zinc (or titanium) oxide sunscreen which AFAICT maxes out both effectiveness and chemical safety. (And is the best for the fish?) Interestingly, these are the only ingredients that the FDA currently deems both safe and effective.

loading story #48506008
loading story #48505879
loading story #48506597
loading story #48506301
This has been true for a while. Sadly.
Japanese ones are also much better. I like Anessa Milk, it also doesn't stain as bad as some others.
> A peer-approval system would work both ways. Europe would also take into account FDA decisions

This doesn't seem like a given at all. Just because the FDA accepts EMA approvals wouldn't mean the EMA would accept FDA ones and as a European, I wouldn't want it to.

I have a lot more trust in the EMA than the FDA.

The FDA’s big claim to fame is not approving thalidomide when European regulators did, preventing a bunch of birth defects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide
loading story #48505533
(2024)

More recently:

FDA Expands Sunscreen Options for the First Time in 20 Years to Add Bemotrizinol

https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-expa...

(https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48466007)

Can't the free market just make this problem go away?
loading story #48505377
loading story #48505227
loading story #48505344
loading story #48505274
loading story #48505347
loading story #48505375
loading story #48505295
{"deleted":true,"id":48505372,"parent":48503940,"time":1781278015,"type":"comment"}