Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Misleading

> Among the 270 jobs in the 1950 U.S. census, only one job was automated away — elevator operator. But many others were rendered obsolete by new technology, like the job of telegraph operator.

In that same time farm jobs went from 15% of the workforce to 2%.

They seem to address that: "This is sharply different from occupations such as agriculture in which labor demand was famously decimated due to mechanization and automation. The difference is that the amount of calories people consume is relatively fixed — even a 25% increase led to the obesity epidemic — whereas the amount of software produced has grown a millionfold."
Farm employment itself has decreased 4x compared to 1950 (the % figure overstates it since the total workforce is larger). However if we consider the broader "food" industry employment has increased substantially.

Thus we may see "coder" employment decrease but the broader "software/tech" industry increase in employment.

loading story #48491312
Look up the logging industry. Like 95% of those jobs are automated now, but they like to blame an owl
yep. selective usage of stats at their best. how about factories too? conveyer belts? people losing their jobs all the time whenever automation comes in. and we just "hope" for the best they can find jobs or delusional hopefulness swinging into extremes ("be generalist!", "be specialist!", "work in service!", "learn to code!", "learn to mine coal!"), all incoherent. just listen to @pmarca to see how totally lost and incoherent tech leadership is.

check Stripe Press latest on indutrial automation: https://press.stripe.com/origins-of-efficiency