Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
Reflected inertia does scale as the square of the gear ratio but it's a bit misleading unless you also consider the change in rotor inertia, which scales as a cube of the rotor radius (as the article points out).

The other side of the scaling laws say that motor torque scales as a square of air gap radius (roughly rotor radius), and output torque scales as linearly with gearing ratio.

When you balance these out, the reflected inertia depends on the inverse of power dissipated for a fixed output torque.

In an ideal world, your total reflected inertia is independent of the gearbox and largely depends on the motor fill factor and how hot you can run it.