Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
This might be more of a gen Z and zillennial thing but the embedding of black & white purity tests in almost all social settings is a big factor.

You must have opinion and they all must align perfectly like mine. Case and point people's behaviors around the 2024 election.

Russian? You better be the most outspoken anti Putin-ist . Jewish? You better be sorry for the Zionists at every turn. Queer? Oh sorry you work for Google and even if your department has nothing to do with the current bads you're bad too, stop stealing from artists with AI. Those are some extreme and blatant examples but ones I've witnessed cause people to get excommunicated no matter how bleeding of a heart they have for the causes people rhetorically crucify them over.

I'm not going to pretend you should be fine if say, a literal unironic nazi is trying to cozy up in your book club, or some clown is constantly bringing up "hot takes" needlessly on your baseball club. But these constant purity tests typically remove all nuance and leave both sides heavily alienated, leaving many to fall into a hedgehog's dilemma of fearing interactions lest they're accused of things they simply are not.

This. Every disagreement turns almost instantly into dislike.

I feel it wasn't always like this. One should be able to have a debate about s.th. with different opinions and still be friends.