Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Start your meetings at 5 minutes past

https://philipotoole.com/start-your-meetings-at-5-minutes-past/
loading story #46563275
> there is social pressure not to allow meetings to run much past the top of the hour.

I've never seen this pressure.

> meetings rarely started on the dot anyway before this change.

It's like I live in an entirely different world.

Start meetings when they say they're going to start. People will learn to show up quickly. I think that works better than trying to psychologically game people into cooperation. That just starts the classic treadmill. You might have that one friend that you tell to show up half an hour before everyone else. They mentally add the half hour back because you're always giving such early times. Better IMO to just keep things simple. Let people leave when they need to. Show up on time.

> People will learn to show up quickly.

My bosses (leadership) are in meetings literally all day long. Them showing up 5 minutes late to an internal meeting has nothing to do with them "learning". It's entirely about priorities. Teaching them to "show up on time" does nothing and only hurts me for being obtuse with them.

loading story #46563940
Well, yes, but also the critical attendees (people with something substantial to add) of the meeting aren't there on time, so the meeting cannot start on time, which leads to a culture where no one shows up on time. I was flummoxed yesterday when an SVP scheduled a large meeting and was the only critical attendee, and started exactly on time, within seconds. I showed up at the top of the hour + 49 seconds and missed at least 30 seconds of content.
loading story #46562257
In the early 90s I had a new department director who would bring a kitchen timer to every meeting. Meetings started on precisely on time and the timer was set to 22 minutes. When that bell rung, you could finish the thought, but the meeting would break at the 25 minute mark. If you didn’t accomplish the agenda, another meeting could be set, but it needed to be at least 2 hours after the one that just broke. Even meetings without him had to follow the rule. He also had a request that were were supposed to follow if we could, which was to allow ourselves to only schedule one meeting in an hour.

Obviously it was pretty chaotic at first and I recall us being pretty brutal in our assessment of his “crazy meeting quirk”. However after a few weeks something pretty interesting happened:

- Brevity and productive discussion became common. People usually went with their best opinion

- we usually finished the agenda (probably because we set reasonable agendas for 22 mis) and rarely needed that rollover meeting

- we spent more time at our desks actually doing instead of just talking about doing. I recall that team being really productive overall.

Later when I moved into leadership roles I attempted to bring this methodology but my own leadership generally was not supportive enough to allow me to be as rigid and I didn’t see the same success with the method…but to this day 32+ years later I still think it had merit.

I had asked him where he had learned it. My recollection is that he formulated it after reading that the average person’s attention span in a meeting was 27 minutes and he figured no one was productive after that, so he decided it was pointless to go longer.

loading story #46591597
I find it interesting when people such as the writer of the linked post take their experience and think it can just be applied to everyone else, and it'll always be a positive outcome.
A team I once ran made rules their meetings would end 5 minutes early, to create some space. We didn’t have the power to change the whole org, but we could control team meetings to create space before other meetings. Since the whole team was on board with this, there was always someone who would call out that it was time for the meeting to end, to prevent them running long.

At the same time, we had a rule that meetings would start when they say they start. This was after being incredibly frustrated by a guy on another team who would schedule his meetings to start on the hour, but then display a message that said we’d start at 5 after, to give people time to join, assuming other meetings would run long. This felt like he was wasting everyone’s time who showed up on time, and had the net effect of everyone showing up late to his meetings. If people learned they should show up late to his meetings, they can learn to show up on time to our meetings. Then we can stop waiting around hoping that everyone shows up. When someone shows up late to a meeting that’s already well underway, that sends a strong signal that they should be on time for the next one.

loading story #46561749
loading story #46563844
loading story #46565122
loading story #46563592
loading story #46562828
loading story #46563741
loading story #46564978
loading story #46562023
loading story #46566247
loading story #46562212
loading story #46568351
loading story #46562025
loading story #46562223
loading story #46563953
loading story #46562929
loading story #46565704
loading story #46564511
loading story #46566869
loading story #46561741
loading story #46561813
loading story #46564410
loading story #46565060
loading story #46562355
loading story #46567769
loading story #46567886
loading story #46565527
loading story #46563445
loading story #46563202
loading story #46565920
loading story #46564036
loading story #46561798
loading story #46565674
loading story #46561905
loading story #46569323
loading story #46587636
loading story #46563581
loading story #46566321
loading story #46564369
loading story #46565485
loading story #46565579
loading story #46567778
loading story #46562043
loading story #46562765
loading story #46563553
loading story #46565894
loading story #46565245
loading story #46565153
loading story #46567683
loading story #46561841
loading story #46564691
loading story #46564629
loading story #46567444
loading story #46568598
loading story #46562085
loading story #46565286
loading story #46568238
loading story #46563762
loading story #46570195
loading story #46565028
loading story #46561940
loading story #46561913
loading story #46569962
loading story #46572234
loading story #46563798
loading story #46565967
loading story #46563161
loading story #46566692
loading story #46561904
loading story #46565318
loading story #46561446
loading story #46561693
loading story #46564826
loading story #46564802
loading story #46564754