Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
What do you suggest?
loading story #43130292
loading story #43128805
I quite like the idea of a united EU army. It's something that's been floated quite a bit recently.
"I quite like the idea of a united EU army."

Won't happen, at least not in any meaningful form.

Baltics or Poland are existentially threatened by Russia, Spain or even Germany are not, even if Russia can do a limited damage to them. What is supposed to create "unity" in that regard? What would force Spain to contribute as much as, let's say, Finland? We can see even now, with all these US threats, not every NATO country was willing to increase its spending on military. And even more importantly, who is going to command such EU army? Commission?

loading story #43130220
I think it has to be the french president, they’re the only EU country with nukes (I dont see UK as EU at this point)
Well, Macron is probably the only European leader that, declaratively at least, would like to push for more agency for Europe. Issue is that, for now, he offers only words. He already is trying to back down from the idea of sending troops to Ukraine (and number that was proposed was pathetic, considering intensity of this conflict).

Nukes are but a one thing, useful only in specific circumstances, but not sufficient. It is unrealistic to expect France using nukes if Russia attacks Lithuania, for example. Stakes are not justifying such escalation.

European countries lack conventional means: UAV, artillery, missiles. And soldiers.

loading story #43130183
loading story #43131402
I, on the other hand (as an EU citizen), would like to not be drafted to fight in a conflict by two random governments of countries I don't live in and share nothing ideologically with. Sure, we can all do taxes together, share the currency, etc. I know that NATO already is that way, but the EU is not a military alliance and should never be.
loading story #43132502
loading story #43132740
I would like to see unified command and control facilities, interoperability agreements, combined purchasing and a within EU military industrial plan. Most of this already exists in the form of NATO and can be repurposed for near $0.

There is no need for anything more, nor are the institutions really designed for a single president / general to direct everyone in a conflict. Putting in place all the capabilities to work together in a conflict should be done however.

Zelinsky was by no means the first, I heard talks of this since the crimean annexation.
By Zelensky, I think.

What? I'm pretty sure he said that.

Yeah, here it is: 'Army of Europe' needed to challenge Russia, says Zelensky

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgl27x74wpo

loading story #43128874
loading story #43128885
Yes, united behind a strong upright leader, or even führer.