Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Apple pulls data protection tool after UK government security row

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cgj54eq4vejo
loading story #43129261
loading story #43130870
loading story #43131557
loading story #43132180
loading story #43130028
loading story #43136658
loading story #43129901
loading story #43129523
loading story #43130256
loading story #43130071
loading story #43131405
loading story #43128502
loading story #43131507
loading story #43135376
loading story #43131140
loading story #43128697
loading story #43129498
loading story #43130436
loading story #43130624
loading story #43128894
loading story #43137354
loading story #43130417
loading story #43128867
loading story #43128626
loading story #43134806
loading story #43131759
loading story #43135843
loading story #43129619
loading story #43129240
loading story #43130111
loading story #43128402
loading story #43135551
loading story #43130921
loading story #43134799
loading story #43135948
loading story #43130626
loading story #43131335
loading story #43129580
loading story #43131055
loading story #43134377
loading story #43129089
loading story #43132797
loading story #43131602
loading story #43130988
loading story #43128839
loading story #43128485
loading story #43133537
loading story #43137170
loading story #43136786
loading story #43130370
loading story #43133444
loading story #43130736
loading story #43131970
loading story #43133293
loading story #43129491
loading story #43130468
loading story #43135270
loading story #43129338
loading story #43135977
loading story #43128820
loading story #43129861
loading story #43132005
loading story #43130304
loading story #43128964
loading story #43131485
loading story #43132869
loading story #43132539
loading story #43136373
loading story #43131385
loading story #43131079
loading story #43130055
loading story #43129172
loading story #43129509
loading story #43130533
loading story #43129556
loading story #43133846
loading story #43135893
loading story #43132608
loading story #43128912
loading story #43130633
loading story #43130239
loading story #43128472
loading story #43134929
loading story #43133693
loading story #43133548
loading story #43128953
loading story #43129798
loading story #43131223
loading story #43130577
loading story #43129212
loading story #43129177
loading story #43130043
loading story #43129478
loading story #43130040
loading story #43134333
loading story #43129385
loading story #43129339
loading story #43130358
loading story #43131212
As someone currently a citizen of the UK, what are my best emigration opportunities?
loading story #43131076
loading story #43128660
loading story #43128604
Depends on what you’re after * Australia * United States * Singapore * Dubai * Europe (Belgium/Switzerland/Netherlands)
If you're after freedom, you absolutely do not want Singapore or Dubai.
The United States has the strongest laws for freedom of speech. You can't get arrested and face years of criminal legal trials, ending in an £800 fine for making a joke with your dog in America. Police won't show up at your house for Facebook posts like they do in Aussiestan. American courts probably won't take your infant away from you and force a medical procedure on it like in Kiwistan just because you wanted to use your own blood donors for the operation.

It's been degrading in the US too. Xitter is not at all a free speech platform and that technocrat says whatever he has to for popularity until he can chip your brain. Cutting a few million in wasteful government spending doesn't make up for how he loves China and deeply desires their level of autocracy.

America's laws have somehow held in-spite of presidents that seek to crush it (yes, both of them, both sides. They're the same. Stop believing the headlines and read the damn articles). Although defamation law has been weaponized to neuter some forms of speech and reporting.

There is an internal push by the CIA in America to further destabilize it and cause radical elements in the fake-left and fake-right to call for more authoritarianism. It's not a great nation, but sadly it is the last bastion of true liberty .. and it's eroding every day from every side.

In 20 years there might not be anywhere to flee to. Fight for your country. They can't put every British person in prison if everyone decided to tell the truth.

> American courts probably won't take your infant away from you and force a medical procedure on it like in Kiwistan just because you wanted to use your own blood donors for the operation.

Whenever someone writes "just" in a case like this I can tell there's a complicated, ugly legal case that's being grossly misrepresented, and quite possibly one where no responsible journalist is reporting because of child privacy issues/laws.

The problem with both British and American surveillance state authoritarianism is it's hugely popular with the public when used against the ""wrong"" people. You might have "free speech" (subject to qualifications such as Comstock and their modern day equivalents) but you're much, much less likely to be shot and killed by the police - or a random stranger - in the UK.

this is not a free speech issue, it's about key escrow

and the US invented technical crypto backdoors

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip

That said, American leadership is still fine with dragnet surveillance and coercing corporations to lie to their audience: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/12/apple-admits-to-...

Being American has it's perks, but privacy isn't one of them.

Australia is the worst of all
Of the whole list, if the Investigatory Powers Act is what you didn't like, I'd pick Switzerland first, then Belgium/Netherlands.

Of course, that assumes you're fluent in the local languages. Hoe goed spreekt u Nederlands?

I made a jump to Germany in 2018, and, thanks to learning a new language, have had a front-row seat to how flat the real Dunning Kruger effect really is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Dunning–Kruger_Effect2.sv...

Dubai, even as an international hub where you may be able to get by with English — لا تضيع وقتك باستخدام دولينجو لتعلم اللغة العربية، لقد حاولت خلال الوباء وما زلت لا أعرف الأبجدية — is much more authoritarian than the UK. Similar for Singapore.

If you're monolingual, and privacy is your concern, then the US is an improvement over Australia.

But also consider Canada and Ireland.

Ireland isn't in Five Eyes, Canada is, but also Canada is slightly further away from the madness of Trump etc. than any company still inside the USA.

I'm not even sure what's going to happen with the US federal government given that DOGE cannot meet its stated goals even by deleting all discretionary-budget federal agencies like the NSA, CIA, FBI, all branches of the armed forces, etc. but on the other hand the private sector is busy doing a huge volume of spying anyway in the name of selling adverts… chaos is impossible to predict, and you should want to predict things at least a few years out if you're going to the trouble of relocating.

loading story #43129532
Australia is even more everyone-is-a-cop than the UK, and is doing this exact same shit for the exact same reason.
loading story #43128672
loading story #43128404
loading story #43128539
loading story #43128306
loading story #43130793
loading story #43131926