Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Carbon capture more costly than switching to renewables, researchers find

https://techxplore.com/news/2025-02-carbon-capture-renewables.html
loading story #43059557
loading story #43060822
loading story #43059917
loading story #43059442
loading story #43060442
loading story #43061753
loading story #43061863
loading story #43059437
loading story #43060082
loading story #43059665
loading story #43060265
loading story #43059596
loading story #43062470
loading story #43067485
loading story #43060199
Would love to have someone knowledgeable share why carbon capture is more viable than planting trees. I always thought the idea we need technology to capture carbon is silly, but never bothered enough to research more on it
The way to look at it is: there are two carbon cycles. A long cycle (proto-plankton dies, gets carbonized over millions of years, is pumped up, burned, and ends up in the atmosphere), and a short cycle (tree dies, is burned / rots, and ends up in the atmosphere).

If all we do is burn trees, there is no problem. We're not adding CO2 to the atmosphere that wasn't there before. The problem is that the stuff we pump up was not there before.

So capturing in trees is at best a temporary solution. In 20 / 30 years that tree dies and is burnt or rots, and so the CO2 is released again. At best it may buy us some time while we learn to do with less oil. But it's crazy talk to do a weekend in Thailand and then "offset it with trees". That's like saying "I was broke, but I found $100 on the street, now life can continue as before".

I won't even mention the fact that large parts of the "offset economy" are essentially fraud. People that own a swath of forrest declaring "I was going to cut these 10 km2 of forrest and prevent any new tree on it, but now I won't" just so that they can get carbon credits. Even if it is painfully obvious that they never intended to do that.

loading story #43059446
loading story #43059608
loading story #43059544
loading story #43059534
loading story #43059477
loading story #43059484
loading story #43060942
I got some solar panels. Did the math and was impressed that they would pay for themselves in around just 2 years.

It's a bit sad that to make money you need money, but I do recommend anyone who can afford it to just install them.

For most people the break-even is longer than that. Net-metering is an unjustified gift from non-paneled ratepayers to ratepayers with solar panels.
loading story #43061694
loading story #43059695
loading story #43060800
loading story #43060067
loading story #43059642
loading story #43060768
loading story #43064009
Carbon capture is one of the most absurd ideas I've ever heard, given the array of already available options.
Planting trees is also a form of carbon capture. They literally capture carbon from the environment and release oxygen. It's as if they natural evolved to counterbalance animals.

Sadly, when people talk about "carbon capture" techniques, they're never talking about planting trees.

loading story #43065769
loading story #43060998
loading story #43060484
It's not a long list, and among them is pumping sulfur in the stratosphere. It stops sounding so absurd compared to what's viable, nevermind politically.
loading story #43059987
loading story #43060914
loading story #43059757
loading story #43070044
loading story #43060746
loading story #43073307
loading story #43062553
loading story #43061399
loading story #43067739
loading story #43060228
loading story #43062590
loading story #43060360
loading story #43062244
loading story #43060885
loading story #43059633
loading story #43073699
loading story #43062636
loading story #43059904
loading story #43059555
loading story #43061698
loading story #43069760
loading story #43059769
loading story #43060059
loading story #43059815
loading story #43061325
loading story #43059589
loading story #43060789
loading story #43060327
loading story #43059508
loading story #43060171
loading story #43071429
loading story #43059401
loading story #43061014
loading story #43065196
loading story #43100910
loading story #43061286
loading story #43062005
loading story #43074597
loading story #43060101
loading story #43060123
loading story #43061928
loading story #43060066
loading story #43060646
loading story #43062516
loading story #43062505
loading story #43060541
loading story #43061789
loading story #43062807
loading story #43059764