On the surface but then they label you a dangerous offender and they keep you in jail. Paul Bernardino is a good example.

The differences in the system probably have more to do with electing vs appointing. Electing is more likely to send someone tougher on crime vs well balance.If officials were elected in Canada you would see the same outcome.

Not to mention private vs public prisons and when you make it a business you have to find new customers vs a cost center you want to limit.