Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

    > Where is the problem?
When the inequality gap widens, it has broader long term socioeconomic impact. The civil rights era is not even a century behind us and many fellow Americans are still effectively competing against others that have been given a generational "head start".

Does this matter to you? This depends on the type of society you want to live in and be a part of. My take? None of us live in a vacuum in isolation; we live in a country of 300+ million people. My neighbor's are Iranian, Syrian, Turkish/German, French/Moroccan, Indian, East Asian and all lovely people.

The problem DEI programs should solve is a systemic one where hiring practices might otherwise pass on qualified minority candidates or may not even be presented to them in the first place. The implementation of many programs is questionable, but the objective and why have some form of policy that focuses on broader inclusivity in the hiring process should not be: I want a better America for everyone and not just some subset of Americans.

Or maybe theres just less people from certain cultures that want to be a software developer.

Whats next, you want to force more white people to become developers because ethnic Indian devs are becoming too populous in the industry.

In my country most of the blacks are in London and so we have no black devs in our office. We arent going to go out and find some to hire.

I decided to look up the demographics on Wikipedia. London does indeed have a higher percentage black population than the rest of the country, but Manchester and Birmingham are very similar, whilst other major cities where you're likely to find the most tech companies have around 5%.

London: 54% white, 14% black

Manchester: 57% white, 12% black

Birmingham: 49% white, 11% black

Bristol: 81% white, 6% black

Leeds: 79% white, 6% black

Sheffield: 80% white, 5% black

Liverpool: 84% white. 4% black

Note: this excludes mixed black and white backgrounds, which make up a decent proportion of people who would describe themselves as black.

So if equal numbers of black people went into tech, and companies hired without bias, then you'd expect at least 1 in 20 people in most tech companies to be black.

You're right that fewer people from black backgrounds are applying to tech jobs, although I think it's a leap to say it's because they "don't want to". It could just as easily be that they find it intimidating, or don't believe they can do it, or they're socialised into other careers. As a company or hiring manager, if you do come across black applicants, it may well be the case that they have had to battle against a lot to get where they are, which shows grit, enthusiasm, and initiative.

loading story #42665536
> Whats next, you want to force more white people to become developers because ethnic Indian devs are becoming too populous in the industry.

You managed to sneak in both a slippery slope fallacy and a straw man in the same argument here. No one said what you're claiming.

loading story #42665545