Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit
> Talking about "technological and political issues" without mentioning any

I don't know why you think none were mentioned - to name one, they link a GitHub issue created against the systemd repository by a Googler complaining that systemd is inappropriately using Google's NTP servers, which at the time were not a public service, and kindly asking for systemd to stop using them.

This request was refused and the issue was closed and locked.

Behaviour like this from the systemd maintainers can only appear bizarre, childish, and unreasonable to any unprejudiced observer, putting their character and integrity into question and casting doubt on whether they should be trusted with the maintenance of software so integral to at least a reasonably large minority of modern Linux systems.

And people forget that this behavior of systemd devs is present in lots of other core projects of the Linux ecosystem.

Unfortunately this makes modern Linux not reliable.

systemd made time servers a compile-time option and a warn if distros are using the default time servers:

https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/554

What's your suggested alternative?

Using pool.ntp.org requires a vendor zone. systemd does not consider itself a vendor, it's the distros shipping systemd which are the vendor and should register and use their own vendor zone.

I don't care about systemd either way, but your own false representation of facts makes your last paragraph apply to your "argument".

> What's your suggested alternative?

That if they do not wish to ship a safe default, they do not ship a default at all.

loading story #41525796