Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit

Flags Are Not Languages

https://www.flagsarenotlanguages.com/blog/
loading story #40263432
loading story #40265829
loading story #40263416
The website argues that using a flag for a language may confuse or even offend users. It argues English would most appropriately be represented by the flag of England, but few people know the flag of England, so English is usually represented by the flag of the UK or the US, neither of which are appropriate because other languages are spoken in the UK and English does not originate from the US.

I would argue that using either the UK or US flag is less likely to confuse anyone than not using any flag, and that anyone offended by this needs to grow a tougher skin.

The fact that any mapping from a language to a flag is to some extent arbitrary does not imply that no mapping at all is better. This sounds like a variation of the Sorites paradox.

Furthermore, I find it amusing that a website dedicated to languages, which are roughly sets of arbitrary conventions we use to communicate, is offended by the choice of another arbitrary convention to communicate.

I know a person from Ireland that doesn't take well to being associated with the "Butcher's apron" as he refers to the flag of Great Britain. Ireland has its own flag and they are very proud of it. And they'll object to any suggestion that they are English.

And of course England has its own flag, which is not the same as that of Great Britain. And of course quite a few countries still using English because they were formerly colonized/oppressed/etc. (take your pick) and might have a thing or two to say about having to deal with the British flag.

There are a lot more languages than countries. And language variations, dialects, etc. And a lot of flag / language combinations are confusing, insulting, historically incorrect, or not that helpful. Like the British, the French were all over the place and there are lots of places that speak French that don't use the French flag. Likewise Spanish is used all over the Americas. India has about 21 official languages (I think, might be more). One of which is English. So, it's complicated for English and it doesn't really get any better for other languages.

Telling people to grow a tougher skin isn't particularly user friendly or that helpful.

loading story #40263923
> less likely to confuse anyone than not using any flag

This doesn't seem obvious to me. I don't think the word "English" is likely to confuse any English speaker.

> anyone offended by this needs to grow a tougher skin

Are you saying this with the personal experience of being from a country that now speaks the language of its colonizer?

loading story #40265432
To give you an example of flags being offensive: most people who would ever choose Belarusian anywhere in any computer system will find the current Belarusian flag offensive because it represents the government that oppresses their culture and represses people who dare use the language in public.

Another example: a lot of people speak Russian outside of Russia. Many of them have nothing to do with Russia and never lived there, and even without the devastating war that Russia is currently waging against Ukraine they don't want to associate their language with Russia and its flag.

loading story #40263838
There's always ISO 639, which has three chances of being acceptable to end users: slim, fat, and none.

What flag would you suggest for http://als.wikipedia.org or http://pdc.wikipedia.org ?

English is the official language of the United Kingdom, so their argument doesn't make sense.
loading story #40263778
loading story #40264655
loading story #40263807
loading story #40263786
loading story #40263716
loading story #40263656
loading story #40263752
loading story #40265873
loading story #40263723
loading story #40263521
loading story #40265406
loading story #40263458
loading story #40263616
loading story #40263422
loading story #40266870
loading story #40267317
loading story #40278794
loading story #40271573
loading story #40265600
loading story #40266647
loading story #40263701
loading story #40263736
loading story #40263445